Reimagining Job Quality Measurement
About
The United States (U.S.) has historically gauged economic health on job quantity rather than quality (i.e., provision of financial stability and equitable advancement opportunities). The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) partnered with several organizations to launch the Job Quality Measurement Initiative (JQMI). This report describes the implementation of JQMI, recommendations for improving data collection and use, and the potential effects these changes could have on the workforce.
Following the COVID-19 pandemic, an opportunity emerged to reshape the U.S. economy to be more inclusive and beneficial and to elevate the measurement of job quality. The focus of JQMI is collaboration among governmental bodies, businesses, and the social sector to improve job quality data collection and utilization.
According to the authors, JQMI can help answer key questions on the economy and labor market, find disparities and solutions, improve decision-making, and support the development of good jobs with equitable pathways. Moreover, they assert that businesses can use enhanced data to make job designs conducive to employees’ well-being and possibly to improve the attraction, retention, productivity, and resilience of workers.
In spring and summer 2022, JQMI convened over 70 leaders and data experts to analyze current measurement systems, identify gaps, and develop actionable recommendations for government, philanthropy, business, and the nonprofit sector to improve job quality measurement. JQMI’s working groups defined “good jobs” as those which centered on economic stability; economic mobility; and equity, respect, and voice. They also developed a set of guiding principles to shape data collection, connection, and analysis.
Based on the engagement of DOL staff and other workforce partners, the authors identified 10 actions to improve job quality measurement: (1) measure what matters to workers; (2) center equity in measurement; (3) increase mandatory human capital data disclosure; (4) link public and private data to gain new insights into the quality of jobs; (5) leverage business data to demonstrate the return on investment from good jobs; (6) revise data systems to include and support the non-W2 workforce; (7) strengthen workforce system metrics to deliver results for workers and businesses; (8) use public and private spending to measure and strengthen equity and good jobs; (9) strengthen state and local capacity for data-driven decision-making to advance good jobs; and (10) invest in strengthening job quality measurement.
Major Findings and Recommendations
Based on JQMI participants’ recommendations for implementing the ten actions, the authors identified nine recommendations categorized as most actionable, most transformative, and most crosscutting.
Most Actionable:
- Gather data to show that good jobs are good investments.
- Invest in creating a job quality data infrastructure.
- Deploy requirements for data disaggregation in workforce and social service programs, administrative data, and federal surveys.
Most Transformative:
- Use public spending to measure and promote job quality and equity.
- Include workers’ voices during data collection.
- Remove harmful assumptions and metrics embedded in workforce and social service systems.
Most Crosscutting:
- Connect administrative and statistical data to better understand the labor market.
- Centralize, standardize, and extend wage records across all states.
- Expand job quality indicators beyond wages.
Materials
Comments
Content Details
Methodology:
Topics:
Target Populations:
Programs:
Geographic Locations:
Industry Sectors:
- Last Updated:
- Created:
- Resource Publication Date: 2022
- Author(s): Mourti, N.; Nellis, L.; Rodriguez, B.; Valle, B.
- Resource Availability: Publicly available
- Posted by: Justin Venneri
- Posted in: Workforce System Strategies